Comparative analysis of the behavior of flat slab with drop panels and beam-slab system using response spectrum method

Authors

  • Satria Dayvano Mangelep Civil Engineering Study Program, Christian University of Indonesia, Jakarta, 13630, Indonesia
  • Sudarno P Tampubolon Civil Engineering Study Program, Christian University of Indonesia, Jakarta, 13630, Indonesia https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9272-7084
  • Setyadi Civil Engineering Study Program, Christian University of Indonesia, Jakarta, 13630, Indonesia

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.22225/jipe.5.1.2026.1-7

Keywords:

flat slab, drop panel, beam-slab system, response spectrum analysis, story drift

Abstract

The choice of floor system influences building height and seismic behavior. This study compares a beam-slab system (Model 1) and a flat slab with drop panels (Model 2) for a five-story reinforced concrete office building in Banda Aceh on site class SE and in seismic design category D. Response spectrum analysis was performed in ETABS V.22 in accordance with SNI 1726:2019, and the fundamental period, base shear, story drift, and slab deflection were compared. Model 1 had shorter fundamental periods than Model 2 in both directions, at 0.932 s versus 0.981 s in the x-direction and 0.951 s versus 0.980 s in the y-direction. Its base shear was also lower, at 1666 kN versus 1846.85 kN, consistent with its lower seismic weight. The maximum story drift of Model 1 was 17.39% lower in the x-direction, at 51.49 mm versus 62.33 mm, and 20.50% lower in the y-direction, at 49.52 mm versus 62.29 mm, indicating greater lateral stiffness. Conversely, the slab deflection of Model 1 was 10.58 mm, which is 36.7% higher than the 7.74 mm of Model 2, or equivalently 26.84% lower for Model 2. The flat slab with drop panels therefore performs better in slab deflection, whereas the beam-slab system performs better under lateral seismic loads. Because the two models differ in member sizes, these results apply only to the configurations analyzed.

References

[1] B. Anjaneyulu and J. Prakash, “Analysis And Design Of Flat Slab By Using Etabs Software,” International Journal of Science Engineering and Advance Technology, IJSEAT, vol. 4, no. 2, 2016, [Online]. Available: www.ijseat.com

[2] T. I Gusti Ngurah Agung Eka Arya, M. Nyoman Parthin Indra, S. I Nengah, T. I Wayan Gde Erick, and S. Putu Ellsa, “Analysis of Penel Drop-Off on Shear Slip at Flat Slab in The Animal Hospital Education Building of The Faculty of Veterinary Medicine (RSHP-FKH), Udayana University,” Journal of Infrastructure Planning and Engineering (JIPE), vol. 2, no. 2, pp. 23–26, Dec. 2023, doi: 10.22225/jipe.2.2.2023.23-26.

[3] S. Borkar, K. Dabhekar, I. Khedikar, and S. Jaju, “Analysis of Flat Slab Structures in Comparison with Conventional Slab Structures,” in IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science, IOP Publishing Ltd, Aug. 2021. doi: 10.1088/1755-1315/822/1/012049.

[4] S. A. R. S. Hasibuan, “Investigation of the Influence of Drop Panels on Natural Period of Vibration of Flat Slab Building Structures,” Scholars Journal of Engineering and Technology, vol. 12, no. 06, pp. 185–191, Jun. 2024, doi: 10.36347/sjet.2024.v12i06.002.

[5] Dewa Ngakan Made Dwiva Cahyana, I Nengah Sinarta, and I Putu Ellsa Sarassantika, “The design of the flat slab system with drop panel in the Sukawati market building,” Journal of Infrastructure Planning and Engineering (JIPE), vol. 1, no. 2, pp. 75–80, Oct. 2022, doi: 10.22225/jipe.1.2.2022.75-80.

[6] P. Hnin Thu Htun, M. Nyan Phone, and M. Kyaw Zeyar Win, “Comparative Study on Analysis and Design between Flat Slab and Flat Plate System for RC Building,” 2018. [Online]. Available: www.ijsea.com`313com`com`313

[7] Badan Standardisasi Nasional, “SNI 2847:2019 Persyaratan beton struktural untuk bangunan gedung,” 2019.

[8] Badan Standardisasi Nasional, “SNI 1727:2020 Beban desain minimum dan kriteria terkait untuk bangunan gedung dan struktur lain,” 2020.

[9] Badan Standardisasi Nasional, “SNI-1726-2019 Tata cara perencanaan ketahanan gempa untuk struktur bangunan gedung dan nongedung,” 2019.

[10] S. A. R. S. Hasibuan, H. Prayuda, A. Alisibramulisi, S. H. Adnan, and T. A. R. Hussin, “Enhancing seismic resilience: the role of drop panels in building structures using pushover analysis,” International Journal of Advanced Technology and Engineering Exploration, vol. 12, no. 127, pp. 854–867, 2025, doi: 10.19101/IJATEE.2025.121220095.

[11] A. T. Munthe and G. Jatmiko, “Planning Parking Building Using Flat Slab and Drop Panel as a Replacement Conventional Beam with Analyzing Bending Moment Value & Sliding Style Based On SNI 1726-2012,” Journal of World Conference, vol. 2, no. 3, 2020, [Online]. Available: http://proceedings.worldconference.id.

[12] S. Singh Bhaduria and N. Chhugani, “Comparative Analysis and Design of Flat and Grid Slab System With Conventional Slab System,” International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology, 2017, [Online]. Available: www.irjet.net

[13] M. Mahamid, M. Kamara, and L. C. Novak, “Historical Perspective on the Evolution of Two-Way Slab Design,” 2012. [Online]. Available: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/304452017

[14] D. Coronelli et al., “Flat slab response for seismic and cyclic actions prediction with numerical models,” Eng Struct, vol. 289, 2023, doi: 10.1016/j.engstruct.2023.116307.

[15] S. Hasibuan, Y. Anisa, F. Asmi, A. Ridwan, and R. Salam, “KONTRIBUSI DROP PANEL PADA STRUKTUR GEDUNG TIPE FLAT SLAB,” JOURNAL OF CIVIL ENGINEERING BUILDING AND TRANSPORTATION, vol. 6, no. 2, 2022.

[16] I. M. N. Hartawan, M. Nyoman Parthin Indra, I. N. S. I Nengah Sinarta, T. I Wayan Gde Erick, and S. I Putu Ellsa, “DEFLECTION OF FLAT FLAT SLAB WITH DROP PANELS IN THE G2 BUILDING AT WARMADEWA UNIVERSITY,” Journal of Infrastructure Planning and Engineering (JIPE), vol. 2, no. 2, 2023, doi: 10.22225/jipe.2.2.2023.27-32.

[17] S. Tampubolon, P. Simanjuntak, G. P. Tarapandjang, and I Putu Ellsa Sarassantika, “The Performance Analysis of High-Rise Building Structure Based on SNI 03-1726-2012 and SNI 03-1726-2019 (Case Study: Tower 1 Transit-Oriented Development Apartment Pondok Cina, Depok),” Journal of Infrastructure Planning and Engineering (JIPE), vol. 2, no. 1, pp. 36–41, Jun. 2023, doi: 10.22225/jipe.2.1.2023.36-41.

[18] S. P. Tampubolon, “Comparison of High-Rise Building Structural Performance Using Response Spectrum Method SNI 03-1726-2019 and FEMA-154 Rapid Visual Screening (RVS),” 2023. [Online]. Available: https://publishing.impola.co.id/index.php/MIJR

[19] S. P. Tampubolon, P. Halawa, and O. Padua, “Analysis Behaviour of Podium-Type Buildings with Special Moment Resisting Frame (SMRF) and Dual System Using the Response spectrum Method,” 2025. [Online]. Available: https://publishing.impola.co.id/index.php/ISERJournal

[20] E. Nehe, P. Simanjuntak, and S. P. Tampubolon, “Evaluation of the Performance of High-Rise Building Structures With Plan ‘H’ Shaped For Earthquake With Height Increase (Case Study: Apartment Urban Sky-Bekasi),” in IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science, IOP Publishing Ltd, Nov. 2021. doi: 10.1088/1755-1315/878/1/012053.

[21] P. G. Asteris, C. C. Repapis, A. K. Tsaris, F. Di Trapani, and L. Cavaleri, “Parameters affecting the fundamental period of infilled RC frame structures,” Earthquake and Structures, vol. 9, no. 5, pp. 999–1028, 2015, doi: 10.12989/eas.2015.9.5.999.

[22] T. Ucar and O. Merter, “Derivation of Energy-Based Base Shear Force Coefficient Considering Hysteretic Behavior and P-Delta Effects,” Earthquake Engineering and Engineering Vibration, vol. 17, no. 1, pp. 149–163, Jan. 2018, doi: 10.1007/s11803-018-0431-3.

[23] D. A. Sharapov, T. H. Gebre, and Y. M. Ali, “The Effect of Story Drift in A Multi-Story Building Under The Influence of An Earthquake,” Structural Mechanics of Engineering Constructions and Buildings, vol. 17, no. 3, pp. 270–277, Oct. 2021, doi: 10.22363/1815-5235-2021-17-3-270-277.

[24] I Made Dwi Permana Putra, N. K. A. Agustini, and I. G. A. P. Eryani, “Analysis of Deviation Behavior in The Sman 2 Abiansemal Building With The SRPMK System and Flat Slab,” Journal of Infrastructure Planning and Engineering, vol. 4, no. 1, pp. 39–44, May 2025, doi: 10.22225/jipe.4.1.2025.39-44.

[25] Tampubolon Sudarno P, “Analisa Perilaku Balok Beton Bertulang dengan Menggunakan Simulasi VecTor2,” JURNAL REKAYASA KONSTRUKSI MEKANIKA SIPIL, vol. 03, no. 02, 2020.

[26] A. K. Sawwalakhe and P. D. Pachpor, “Comparative Study of Conventional Slab, Flat Slab and Grid Slab Using ETABS,” IOP Conf Ser Mater Sci Eng, vol. 1197, no. 1, p. 012020, Nov. 2021, doi: 10.1088/1757-899x/1197/1/012020.

[27] S. Borkar, I. Khedikar, and K. Dabhekar, “Analysis of Flat Slab Structure and Conventional Slab Structure,” JETIR, 2021. [Online]. Available: www.jetir.org

[28] V. Malviya and J. N. Vyas, “Comparison Study of Flat Slab and Conventional Slab,” International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology, 2021, [Online]. Available: www.irjet.net

Downloads

Published

2026-04-30

Issue

Section

Articles